The idea behind a convertible crib is pretty simple: buy one piece of furniture that grows with your kid instead of buying three. The Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib with Drawer checks all the right boxes on paper — it starts as a crib, then shifts into a toddler bed, a daybed, and eventually a full-size bed. Plus, there’s storage underneath. You can even get it in multiple colors. It sounds like one of those “why doesn’t everyone do this” kinds of products.

But crib buying isn’t just about ticking off features on a checklist. It’s about finding something that won’t wobble mid-night-feed, that holds up when your baby turns into a toddler who tests boundaries — and crib rails. It’s about finishes that don’t chip after five months, drawers that don’t jam every third pull, and assembly that doesn’t make you rethink all your life choices.

This review breaks down the Graco Hadley crib from the ground up — materials, construction, design, value, and long-term quirks that don’t show up in the product descriptions. No hype. No guesswork. Just a close look at what actually matters when this thing lives in your house for years.

If you’re debating whether this crib makes sense for your setup (or trying to avoid a regret purchase), this should help.

Build Quality & Durability

So here’s the thing — from a distance, the Graco Hadley crib looks solid. And to be fair, once it’s fully assembled and locked into place, the core frame does hold steady. The main structure is made of New Zealand pine, but there’s a noticeable mix of engineered wood and composite materials too. You feel it more in the drawer and the backboard than in the rails or slats. That mix isn’t unusual in this price range, but it’s worth calling out if you’re expecting 100% hardwood.

Durability-wise, it’s a mixed bag. The crib part itself — slats, base, and frame — seems built to last through a few years of regular use. No significant shifting, no creaking under weight, and it doesn’t start to “loosen” with day-to-day movement like some cheaper models do. But small things? That’s where it gets iffy.

The paint finish is one of the first areas that starts to show wear. Even in spots that don’t get much contact, there can be small chips or flaking — not catastrophic, but not ideal either, especially if you’ve got a teether. Chipped paint on a crib rail is the kind of issue that makes you pause, even if it’s technically non-toxic.

The drawer? That’s another weak point. The construction feels light and slightly misaligned from the jump, and over time, the track can warp or shift just enough that it starts catching or sagging. One side might sit lower than the other, even if you’re not overloading it. If you’re expecting this drawer to be a smooth-glide, heavy-duty organizer — it’s not that.

Bottom line: The crib’s main structure feels dependable enough to last through crib and toddler bed stages. But the finish is fragile, and the drawer might turn into more of a maintenance project than a storage perk. Not a dealbreaker, but something to plan around if you’re looking for long-haul polish.

Ease of Assembly

Let’s talk setup — because this crib doesn’t just show up ready to go. And depending on how your day is going (or how many naps your kid didn’t take), that matters a lot more than it should.

The Graco Hadley comes in a single, heavy box that’s awkward to move solo. Definitely easier with two people — not just for lifting, but for positioning the frame during build. The instructions are surprisingly clear though. There’s no weird translation gaps or “mystery bolt #14” situations. Most steps are straightforward, and they include labeled hardware bags, which helps more than it should.

Still, it’s not exactly quick. Expect to spend at least 1.5 to 2.5 hours on the full build. You’ll be using a hex key (included), and you’ll probably wish you had a power drill with the right bit halfway through. The frame assembly is fairly smooth, but the drawer is where things start to drag. Alignment is fussy, and it’s easy to overtighten or strip screws if you’re not careful. A few users have run into issues with misdrilled holes, meaning the drawer either won’t sit flush or keeps sliding off its tracks. Not in every unit — but enough to flag.

Also worth noting: There are no decorative screw covers, so once assembled, you’ll see exposed hardware around the crib. It doesn’t affect performance, but visually? It gives the whole piece a slightly unfinished feel — something that stands out if your nursery is clean and minimal.

Overall: The process won’t make you cry (unless you skip lunch), but it’s not plug-and-play either. One-person setup is possible, but slower. The drawer adds the most frustration, and pre-drilled hole inconsistencies mean some tweaking might be needed. If you’re expecting IKEA-level simplicity, this isn’t quite that.

Design & Aesthetic Fit

Design-wise, the Graco Hadley hits a sweet spot — modern enough to feel updated, simple enough not to take over the room. The lines are clean, almost minimalist, with just enough detail in the panels to keep it from feeling generic. It leans a bit “modern farmhouse” but still works in a more contemporary space. The espresso finish especially gives it a slightly warmer, more traditional vibe — though lighting can pull out red undertones that not everyone expects.

The available color options (black, white, pebble gray, espresso) make it easy to match with different nursery themes, though don’t expect the finish to be flawless. Even right out of the box, you might notice small inconsistencies — tiny paint flecks, minor scratches, maybe a subtle unevenness in gloss. Not dealbreaking on their own, but they do chip away (literally, in some cases) at that “this is a forever piece” feeling.

The attached changing table, available only in certain configurations, adds bulk and limits flexibility. It’s fixed to the right side, so unless your room layout fits that orientation, you’ll need to plan around it. The table is slim and functional, but the open shelving beneath it feels a little basic — fine for baskets or wipes, but not enclosed or deep enough for major storage.

One odd thing: there’s a visible industrial feel in spots. Exposed screws, raw metal hardware — things you don’t see much in higher-end cribs. It doesn’t change how the crib works, but it does shift how it looks once in place. Some people won’t care at all. But if you’re styling a very polished or design-forward space, this might stand out.

Overall: Visually, the Hadley is clean and versatile. It works best in casual, slightly rustic, or modern-traditional setups. The color range is helpful. The changing table placement could be limiting. And while the aesthetic is solid from a few feet away, close-up finishes and exposed hardware might undercut the premium look.

Storage Drawer Functionality

On paper, the built-in storage drawer is a nice bonus. One large drawer, split into two compartments, running the full length of the crib. Sounds useful, especially if you’re tight on space and need every inch to count. And it is — kind of.

When it works properly, the drawer gives you a decent amount of low-key storage. It’s great for extra crib sheets, sleep sacks, diapers, or just the random overflow of baby things that don’t have a home. It slides quietly enough, and the low placement makes it easy to grab stuff without shifting the mattress or leaning too far over.

But this drawer has issues — more often than you’d expect for a feature that should be the simple part. The most consistent problem is alignment. Even after following instructions carefully, one side of the drawer sometimes ends up slightly lower, causing it to drag or catch. There’s no protective top cover, so when the mattress is on the higher settings, the contents are pretty visible — which can make the whole crib look cluttered if you’re not storing things neatly.

The internal divider is fixed, which limits how you organize things. You can’t remove it or adjust the size of each compartment. The glides are basic Euro-style runners — they get the job done but lack smoothness or soft-close action. Over time, the drawer can start feeling wobbly or uneven, especially if the bottom panel flexes under moderate weight. Several units have shown inconsistent craftsmanship here, with holes drilled too wide or too shallow for screws to seat tightly.

And here’s the catch: if your drawer goes off-track or breaks, there’s not an easy replacement path. Parts aren’t always in stock, and you’ll be routed through Storkcraft, not Graco — which has caused some delays and confusion for people trying to fix minor defects.

Bottom line: The drawer is a smart idea and genuinely useful — when it works. But it’s also the component most prone to issues, and there’s not much margin for error in how it’s built. If you’re banking on it as a major storage solution, you might want a backup plan.

Convertibility & Growth Potential

This is the part that often sells people on the Graco Hadley — the promise of one crib that lasts through toddlerhood and beyond. Technically, it’s a 5-in-1: crib, toddler bed, daybed, full-size bed with headboard, and full-size bed with headboard plus footboard. That flexibility does deliver long-term value — at least in theory.

Here’s the catch: none of the conversion kits are included. You’ll need to buy both the toddler guardrail and the full-size bed frame separately. And depending on your timing and where you’re shopping, those kits aren’t always in stock. The product listing can make this unclear if you’re not reading closely — so people end up surprised when they go to convert and realize they’re missing key parts.

When fully set up, the conversion to toddler bed is relatively easy. It uses the same base frame, and you just swap out the front panel for a lower guardrail. There’s no moving the side panels or reconfiguring the structure. It feels sturdy enough, assuming the original crib was assembled well. Same goes for the daybed — just remove the front panel entirely.

The full-size bed conversion requires more of a leap. You’ll need a metal frame to support a standard mattress, and that frame doesn’t come from Graco — or if it does, it’s sold separately through third-party retailers. Alignment can be tricky, especially with older units where wood swelling or paint chipping interferes with bolt fit.

Also, not all mattress types sit well within the frame. For the toddler and daybed stages, you’ll want to make sure your mattress doesn’t ride too high, or the safety guard becomes almost pointless. The recommended mattress dimensions (standard U.S. crib mattress, approx. 52″ x 28″) fit snugly, but there’s not much room for error. If your mattress is even slightly oversized, it can bow the crib sides.

So yes — it grows with your child. But only if you’re willing to track down extra parts and potentially spend another $100–$150 in accessories. That’s not inherently bad — just something to budget for from the start.

Build Quality & Long-Term Durability

This is where things get a bit uneven. The Graco Hadley isn’t flimsy, but calling it “premium” would be generous. It’s a blend of solid New Zealand pine and engineered wood, with visible MDF components in the drawer base and support structures. The result? Sturdy enough when assembled properly — but with some small flaws that tend to show up the longer you use it.

The actual crib frame holds together well. Once it’s bolted into place, it doesn’t wobble, and the slats don’t flex under pressure. It’s stable — not lightweight or shaky like some cheaper models. But not all parts feel equally solid. The drawer and back panel, in particular, show signs of cost-cutting. Drawer glides are basic and can shift over time. Hardware is visible (and stays visible), which makes the whole thing look a bit industrial, especially once the paint starts to chip.

And the paint does chip. Even without much rough use, the finish tends to wear at the edges and corners after a few months. It’s particularly noticeable around the top rails — spots where a teething baby might chew or where hands frequently rest. While the crib is advertised as having a non-toxic finish (and it’s GREENGUARD Gold certified), chipped paint anywhere on a baby’s furniture is a red flag. It’s more aesthetic than functional at first, but it starts to undermine the “safe and long-lasting” promise over time.

Warping is rare in the main frame but more common in the drawer section or panels that house the mattress supports. Some units arrive with misaligned screw holes or small cracks near pressure points — the kind of issues that hint at rushed quality control rather than poor materials. And those inconsistencies matter more in a crib that’s supposed to last through multiple conversion stages.

In the long run, the frame holds up better than the paint and drawer. But this isn’t the kind of crib you disassemble and reassemble every few months. Once it’s set up, it’s best left in place — or risk dealing with loose joints, chipped wood, or screws that never quite bite again the way they did the first time.

Bottom line: It’s built to last in theory, but only if you treat it gently, avoid too much moving, and aren’t counting on a pristine finish past the one-year mark.

Safety, Certification & Compliance

This crib does its homework on safety — at least on paper. It carries the JPMA certification, which means it’s been independently tested to meet or exceed federal safety standards. That includes proper slat spacing, mattress fit, and structural integrity. It also complies with ASTM and CPSIA requirements, and yes — the finish is non-toxic and GREENGUARD Gold Certified for low chemical emissions. All of that adds up to solid baseline reassurance.

Also important: no drop sides. That design — banned by the CPSC since 2010 — is completely absent here. The Hadley sticks to a fixed-rail structure, which is exactly what you want for stability and compliance. For those curious about past issues with Graco cribs: they mostly stem from earlier LaJobi-manufactured models that were recalled well over a decade ago. The current Hadley model isn’t part of that batch and uses different materials and construction.

The adjustable mattress height — three settings — helps match safety needs as your baby grows. High for newborns (easy on your back), middle for sitters, and lowest once they start pulling up or standing. Nothing fancy, but it does the job. The mattress fits snugly with no dangerous gaps if you’re using a standard 52″ x 28″ crib mattress, per the manual. Anything oversized could cause a safety hazard — so size matters here more than some buyers expect.

Still, there’s one overlooked safety factor: paint chipping. While the finish itself is tested for toxicity, chipped paint introduces a gray area. Especially around teething zones, those exposed edges can become rough or flake into tiny bits — not great for a baby who mouths everything. Technically, it’s still compliant, but practically? It can raise eyebrows.

One more detail: there are no anti-tip anchors included — probably because the crib doesn’t technically require one when fully assembled as a crib. But once you start converting it into a toddler or full bed, and especially if you add heavier mattresses or store a lot in the drawer, it’s worth thinking about. It doesn’t feel top-heavy, but again — safety’s in the details.

So yes — it checks the regulatory boxes. But like a lot of nursery furniture, the real-world safety depends on usage: how carefully you assemble it, how well the drawer holds up, and whether that paint starts peeling sooner than you’d expect.

Pros and Cons

Now that all the details are on the table, here’s a breakdown of what actually works — and what doesn’t — in the Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib with Drawer. Some of it is expected, some of it’s quietly frustrating, and a few things are surprisingly helpful once you’ve lived with it (or just spent too much time researching).

Pros:

• True 5-in-1 conversion offers legitimate longevity — crib, toddler bed, daybed, full bed with or without footboard — assuming you’re okay buying extra kits.
• Built-in storage drawer saves space and actually fits more than you’d expect — especially helpful in small nurseries where a separate dresser isn’t an option.
• Modern farmhouse design is versatile enough to fit a wide range of nursery styles without clashing or feeling trendy.
• GREENGUARD Gold and JPMA certified, so the basics (slat spacing, finish emissions, toxic materials) are checked and verified.
• Solid core construction (mostly pine and engineered wood) feels sturdy once it’s set up — not wobbly or hollow.
• Price-to-feature ratio is decent — especially when you factor in the drawer and multiple stages of use.

Cons:

• Finish chips easily, especially on high-contact edges. Doesn’t affect structure, but hurts the look and raises safety questions over time.
• Drawer quality is inconsistent — misaligned tracks, warping, and sagging are common enough to be worth mentioning.
• Exposed hardware and unfinished screw holes make the overall aesthetic feel more “budget” than clean or polished.
• No included guardrail or full-size bed kit, which means extra cost (and some hunting) if you plan to convert later.
• Manufacturing quality control varies — some units arrive with pre-drilled holes out of line, cracked panels, or packaging damage.
• Customer service is handled by Storkcraft, not Graco, which can lead to long wait times, limited replacement part availability, and confusing warranty support.
• Paint durability may not keep up with long-term use, especially through the toddler and bed conversion stages.

So it’s a mixed bag — solid value if you’re willing to work around some quirks, but not flawless. The conversion features and space-saving drawer are strong, but build inconsistencies and finish flaws might make you second-guess the price if you’re looking for something that stays pristine.

Summary Table with Ratings

Here’s a consolidated snapshot of how the Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib with Drawer stacks up across key performance areas. These scores are based on verified product analysis, build quality findings, and real-world functionality — not just surface features.

| Overall Score | 3.8 / 5 | Solid performance, especially for long-term use — if you’re prepared for a few compromises. |

This isn’t a “premium” crib by high-end standards, but it punches above its price point in some areas and underwhelms in others. Definitely not one-size-fits-all — but if conversion flexibility and drawer storage are priorities, it earns a serious look.

Final Conclusion

So here’s where we land.

The Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib with Drawer tries to do a lot — and honestly, it pulls most of it off. The multi-stage design gives it serious staying power, and the built-in drawer actually adds value beyond just being a bullet point on the box. The crib feels sturdy once assembled, the aesthetics are clean enough for most nursery setups, and the core safety certifications are in place.

But it’s not without friction.

The biggest trade-off is consistency. Manufacturing quality varies just enough that you might end up troubleshooting warped drawer panels or realigning pre-drilled holes during setup. The finish looks nice out of the box, but chips too easily — especially frustrating on a product meant to grow with a child for several years. And while conversion options are great in theory, the missing guardrail and full-bed kits make it a modular system you have to piece together over time.

The storage drawer is a smart use of space — but the track issues are hard to ignore, and the open top means you’ll need to store neatly or just live with visible clutter.

Bottom line:
If you’re looking for a convertible crib that offers more functionality than most in this price range — and you’re okay doing a bit of work to get things just right — this one’s worth considering. Especially if space-saving storage is part of your criteria.

But if paint durability, seamless conversion, or perfectly polished design matter more than flexibility or value, this probably isn’t your forever crib.

Helpful Internal Resources:

1. Best Convertible Cribs for Growing with Your Baby
   If you’re still deciding whether the Hadley is your best bet, this guide breaks down top-rated options that also grow with your child.
2. Convertible Crib Buying Guide: Everything You Need to Know
   Learn how convertible cribs work, what to budget for extras like guardrails, and whether it’s better to invest up front or in stages.
3. Are Convertible Cribs Worth It?
   A realistic look at whether these multi-stage cribs actually save money — or just shift the cost down the road.
4. What Is a Convertible Crib?
   A beginner-friendly breakdown of the term and how 4-in-1 and 5-in-1 options compare.
5. Should I Get a Crib with a Changing Table? Pros & Cons
   Since the Hadley includes a drawer (but no changing table), this is a useful side-by-side for parents prioritizing space.
6. The Ultimate Crib Buying Guide for New Parents
   Covers crib materials, dimensions, safety certifications, and setup placement tips.
7. Best Cribs for 2025 That Keep Your Baby Safe & Sound
   A curated, updated list of top cribs — including different formats, budgets, and room sizes.

Trustworthy External References:

• CPSC Bans Drop-Side Cribs (2010)
  This regulation impacts all cribs sold today. The Hadley is compliant by design — no drop sides.
• Past Graco Recalls: Clarification
  Important: This recall only applies to older Graco drop-side models made by LaJobi. The Hadley isn’t affected.
• Safe Sleep Guidelines from the CPSC
  Covers proper mattress use, slat spacing, and recommendations to avoid suffocation hazards — all of which the Hadley aligns with (as long as it’s used correctly).

FAQs

Here are direct, concise answers to the most common questions people search for when considering the Graco Hadley 5-in-1 Convertible Crib with Drawer — based on verified specifications, safety guidance, and performance findings.

What size mattress fits the Graco Hadley crib?

The Hadley fits any standard full-size crib and toddler mattress, typically 52″ x 27.6″. It does not accommodate mini crib mattresses or non-standard sizes. A firm, snug-fitting mattress is required to meet safe sleep standards.

Is the Hadley crib convertible to a toddler bed?

Yes. It converts to a toddler bed, daybed, and full-size bed with headboard. However, the toddler guardrail and full-size bed conversion kit are sold separately, which means extra cost and effort if you plan to use those features.

Are guardrail and full-size conversion kits included?

No. Neither the toddler guardrail nor the full-size metal bed frame is included in the base purchase. These must be purchased separately, and availability can vary depending on the seller. This is a common source of confusion, so double-check listings carefully.

What’s the mattress height adjustment range?

The Hadley crib offers three adjustable mattress height positions. Start at the highest setting for newborns, then lower the mattress as your child grows and begins pulling up or standing. The lowest setting is designed for safe use until your child is climbing out or over 35″ tall.

Does the crib meet safety standards?

Yes. The Hadley crib is JPMA certified and tested to meet or exceed ASTM and CPSIA safety standards. It also uses a non-toxic finish, and the design complies with CPSC regulations — including the ban on drop-side mechanisms.

How heavy is the crib and does it ship in one box?

It ships in a large, heavy box — over 100 lbs. The box includes all parts, hardware, and instructions. Assistance is recommended for carrying or moving it into your home, especially if stairs are involved.

Is the storage drawer removable or adjustable?

No. The drawer is fixed and not designed for removal or repositioning. It sits directly under the mattress frame and moves along basic tracks — but it can misalign during regular use and may require occasional adjustment.

Can I use a changing pad on the drawer surface?

The drawer is not intended for use as a changing surface. There’s no built-in changing table on this model, and the top of the drawer isn’t flat or rated for weight-bearing tasks like diaper changes.

Does the finish chip easily?

In many cases, yes. While the non-toxic finish meets safety regulations, multiple reports and inspections show paint chipping over time, especially on exposed edges or where the crib is in contact with teething children, belts, or toys. This can affect both appearance and ease of cleaning.